Split Emerges Among Some Artists Over Disappearance of Lima Murals

Lima mayor paints over muralsLima’s decision to paint over murals in its historic center has created a division within the city’s artistic community, with one prominent painter defending the municipalities decision to erase the art.

Last week, Lima Mayor Luis Castañeda confirmed that his administration was painting over murals that were commissioned during the administration of his predecessor and political rival, Susana Villarán.

Villarán’s administration, a strong supporter of the arts, had paid for the paintings in an attempt to spruce up Lima’s gritty downtown, whose colonial architecture has for years been falling apart despite the area being named a UNESCO World Heritage Site more than 25 years ago.

Several of the murals have now been covered by yellow paint, the color of Castañeda’s right-wing Solidaridad Nacional party.

“The murals don’t go with the Historic Center of Lima,” Castañeda said.

“Tomorrow [Friday] all of the murals in central Lima are going to disappear,” he said in comments broadcast on AmericaTV.

Most artists and political progressives have come out against Castañeda’s move. On Saturday, the director of Lima Museum of Art (MALI), Natalia Majluf, said she would prefer the murals not be erased. The MALI is Lima’s top arts museum.

“Many people in the cultural field feel the same way,” she said on RPP Noticias. “I understand that those murals were done within a plan for public auctions and they should be respected.”

However at least one prominent artist, Fernando de Szyszlo, supports Castañeda’s decision, saying that the historic center is no place for the brightly-colored murals.

“The murals completely deform the architecture. They distort the vision of the city,” he said.

Sharing is caring!

2 Comments

  1. Villarán neither informed nor requested permission from the U.N. to deface a World Heritage Site with Murals.

    Castañeda did what was required, and removed them.

    “one man’s ‘art’…is another man’s ‘graffiti’ “, as the saying goes.

  2. Gerard Kelly says:

    Joe, you are mistaken and possibly do not understand the mandate of UNESCO.UNESCO has made statements concerning the murals and have clearly made the point that it is not within their mandate to dictate the ways in which the historical sites are maintained.The owners of the properties have also said that they had no issues with the murals. The murals have themselves become part of the historical heritage of the city. Some of these murals have been painted by world class international artists and are very valuable, and add to the artistic heritage of the city. Castañeda consulted no one about this but acted as a dictator and then to add insult used his political colors. How is that adding to the historical significance of these walls? The downtown is still plastered with huge posters of Castañeda, how do they add to the historical significance of the City center? Why does he not put all this energy and money in to actually maintaining the building in the city center? The answer to this: He has no cultural empathy, and really cares nothing for the history, or the buildings.He has done nothing to preserve them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *